Klumpen0815: I wouldn't call that hypocritical.
For some people, rape and torture are worse than murder and I'm inclined to agree.
jamotide: Murder is the worst, that is not a matter of personal preference. It is universally the crime with the highest criminal punishment. Yet players are ok with it, but not much lesser crimes. That by definition hypocritical.
I'm sure you don't understand the word "hypocritical".
That just shows, that the scale of the weight of crimes in the legal system is another one than in big parts of the population. You may define your moral standards by your countries laws (which I doubt, there are always ones with which you'll disagree), but nobody else really does it in every case.
In most western countries the punishment for a banker stealing a million dollars is much less intense than the one for a hobo stealing 100 dollars to get food and the punishment for software piracy and hacking is usually more intense than for rape, do you think this is fair?
Just look at this stuff:
http://www.digitaljournal.com/article/265402 http://aattp.org/steubenville-rape-case-hacker-raided-by-fbi-may-get-more-jail-time-than-rapists/
http://www.globalpost.com/dispatches/globalpost-blogs/rights/opinion-hacking-vs-rape-which-crime-more-deserving-jail-time http://www.democracynow.org/2013/1/7/hacker_group_anonymous_leaks_chilling_video Such legal systems have no right to tell me what is "the worst".
Klumpen0815: Everybody draws the line
somewhere. Where is yours? Pedophilia perks in RPGs?
jamotide: no line, art can do everything
As I've written, not the line for forbidding something but for what is inacceptable for oneself, I'm sure there is something you'd feel a problem with, being able to and getting rewarded for kidnapping and raping a child, murdering it, raping it again, pissing on it, feeding it to your dogs and burning the rest on its mother's lawn maybe? If it's shown pretty realistic, I'm sure you'd feel some kind of wrongness when seeing it, telling me you wouldn't is hypocritical.