Just FWIW, I hadn't used that particular filter, and I'm not sure how to handle both the minutes and the array of possible versions, but hint #3 seems to winnow the pool down to somewhere between 2,195 and 2,107 possible solutions, excluding any that have been guessed.

1875 entries. The tool tip hovering over the entry field will tell you how to use it once you have the information.

Still likelier than winning the lottery!

Guessing... Zeus + Poseidon (Acropolis)

Ah, thanks. I'd guessed at which value of many off the HLTB site, and MaGog seems to use a diff. value.

I'm going to be a bit more careful with assuming mrkgnao used decimals (1875) vs. whole hours (1899) as it's a bit moot for now in making my own selections. ;)

Next up, skipping the soundtrack to arrive at:
Sunrider: Mask of Arcadius

This is probably going to look horrible (I don't have a private account I can share a google sheet from) vs/ what helpo had done last time, but here are the guesses so far alphabetized.

Note that stooner's guess of ATOM RPG is likely ineligible due to the post edit. One duplicate guess so far.

Game # Name
Ancestor's Legacy 7 TheBigCore
ATOM RPG 6 stooner
Blackwell Bundle 16 ConsulCaesar
Chessmaster 9000 5 sanscript
Cossacks Anthology 39 truhlik
Crusader Kings Complete 21 ConsulCaesar
Cultures 1+2 48 BranjoHello
Darksiders III Deluxe Ed 23 blotunga
DustforceDX 4 pkk234
Eador: Genesis 45 PaterAlf
Edna & Harvey: HNE 34 ariaspi
Elder Scrolls III: Morr GOTY 37 PMPMGamer
Fallout (Interplay) 9 paladin181
Flashback 17 BranjoHello
Full Throttle Remastered 24 truhlik
Gabriel Knight: SotF 19 Moonbeam
Ghost of a Tale 33 ConsulCaesar
Gothic 22 Moonbeam
Heroes of M&M 2: Gold 44 bler144
Jack Keane 2: tFW 42 Enebias
Kerbal Space Program 40 TheDudLebowski
LEGO Batman: tV 32 TheMonkofDestiny
Longest Journey, The 26 Moonbeam
Majesty: Gold Edition 38 Sulibor
Might & Magic 6 8 bler144
Might & Magic 7 11 bler144
Might & Magic 7 15 Tauto
Mount and Blade 36 aRealCyborg
Mutant Year Zero 18 CervelloY<
Recettear: AIST 41 TheMonkofDestiny
RiME 43 paladin181
Shadow Tactics: BotS -A&S 25 TheDudLebowski
Sunless Sea 13 gogtrial34987
Sunless Sea: Zubmariner 20 gogtrial34987
Sunless Skies 31 gogtrial34987
Sunrider: Mask of Arcadius 51 gogtrial34987
Zeus + Poseidon (Acropolis) 49 ConsulCaesar

MaGog's value is slightly different because MaGog updates the information from HLTB only once or twice a month, so it is a bit outdated. For the purpose of the clue, the difference does not matter at all.

The word "Everything" is written with a capital E. "Everything" can be found on the HLTB database. It's a 3-hour-long game (Average for all playstyles is 5hrs).

Clue #3 was both a hint and a red herring.

Oh, I understood that. The question was whether it's a 3 hour game or a 5 hour game or a 5.16 hour game for purposes of applying the filter. ;)

I'm assuming (I base this on nothing, btw) that the clue concerned All Playstyles' average, i.e. 5hrs rounded down. The fact that "the difference doesn't matter at all" suggests it may be a much longer game.




2 hours have passed, so my next guess is PC Building Simulator.

Continuing on a theme:

Heroes of Might & Magic 3: Complete

I was going to be in for HSL, but I'm 99.99% positive his wishlist isn't public. So...I'll be in for gogtrial this time, I guess.

Seems interesting, May i guest... TES Morrowind?