KasperHviid: Of course, 18+ people can differentiate between facts and fiction. So can a four year old.
But despite that people "know" that NCIS is fiction, the brain doesn't differentiate all that much, sez science. It has nothing to do with being "dump" or being smart. The brain just has this holistic approach where it collects and uses everything.
A single example:
In German, the word "bridge" is
feminine. But in spanish, it's
masculine.
As a result of this, German speakers describes a bridge as something ladylike: “beautiful, elegant, fragile, peaceful, pretty, slender,”
Spanish speakers, on the other hand, goes like this: “big, dangerous, long, strong, sturdy, towering,”
Considering that this is how the 18+ brain goes about his business, I think the same brain would be more than ready to pick up 'facts' from TV serials.
But believing TV shows to contain fact needs a conscious effort. The brain doesn't work like you described 100% of the time, since there are people who differentiate things, like most of the people on this forum. So it may happen, but its clearly not guaranteed to happen 100% of the time, and I'm guessing it won't if they already know the truth / real information.
Similarly I doubt native German speakers believe the bridge has feminine characteristics, instead just use it without thinking about it.
Shadowstalker16: But yet those are fictional. You can't have political thrillers without contrived psuedo-real enemies and people. Besides, most of these are age-rated 18+ or 16+ and at that stage at least, people should be able to discern fiction from reality to the level that believing such things is more the fault of the person and not the people creating it. I don't see political implications unless the media in question is being used as educational material or official information sources.
morolf: I think that's a bit naive...and frankly, many viewers of NCIS are probably too dumb to understand that it doesn't exactly present a nuanced view of international relations (after all the US even has prominent politicians who confuse Sunnis and Shias...yet still make grand pronouncements about the need for Mideast interventions).
But I probably should leave it at that...don't want to be responsible for this threat getting locked :-))))))
They might be, but isn't it their fault then? Ie if you're thinking fictional TV shows represent reality, isn't the only person at fault yourself? There's a limit to which things can be rearranged around you, but isn't rearranging the unreasonable thing to do when you're a bull in a China shop?
OK I understand, it may be offtopic. I'll stop too.