Oh god, a console war thread. Anyway ...Short story first
I remember when I was buying my first console and the picks were PS2 or XBOX. I lined up all the exclusive titles and started reading up on them. PS2 won easily. And after that, I just stuck with playstation. Hell, I thought every single XBOX360 will come to PC anyway, because it's MS, they are PC company, for christ sake. It started nicely, Gears of War came out, but came with GFWL and a gold subscription. LOL, nice try Microsoft. After that, nothing came out for PC until Fable 3 (i think?), but I did not want that game anyway, hated the idea of running the kingdom. I was really happy when Alan Wake came out. One reason less for me to get a X360. My playlist for X360 looks like this:
Halo 3, Halo Reach, Halo 4. Halo Wars, Gears of War 2, Gears of War 3.
I'll buy the 360 someday to play these games, probably used, since knowing MS, they will probably cut support and production a day after XBONE releases.
And now comes next-gen games exclusives. After 2 generations with playstation, I am sticking with playstation. I am way more attached to their IP. Infamous, God Of War, Uncharted. Sure, I like the look of Ryse, I still dont know shit about Quantum Break, but if you have to watch a tv show, to stay in the loop. Hell no. And MS still hasnt got (announced?) anything like Ratchet&Clank, Jak&Daxter, Sly Cooper. They have Banjoo IP and they dont know what to do with it. When I saw Knack in Feburary, I was really excited, not so much after E3, but the point is Sony actually produces games like that. Fun, colorful platformers.
If you count the currently announced exclusive line-up, MS wins, hands down. But do they have the Order? Nope. Infamous? Nope. Sure, they have Crackdown, but I prefer Infamous. The only genre I don't care about is driving games. So, I dont care about Forza or GT.
I still dont know if my opinion on exclusives is based on the console I own, or do I actually prefer Sony IPs. To me, they seem more .... magical, I guess. I dont think MS is capable of producing a gem like Ico or Shadow of the Colossus.