He has been one of the members of the town I have always been keeping an eye on... what does everyone else think about this?

Hmm, you have a point... but it could just be in the interests of fairness. We're already in trouble without our cop and our doctor. Still, you have a point...

This would fit with my earlier theory about voting tactics - right now, Nazarush, Titanium and FoolalooF / GameRager are my prime suspects.

Albeit with a "demonic possession" inserted somewhere in the middle. I blame Damnation, but that's just me :)

I think that's the default decision. It could destabilise the game otherwise. Remember, at first there were more people on the list (me included), and that many players lost can be a big difference for the outcome now. And it's probably in the rules anyway.

Yes, you're right, but my suspicions still stand. GameRagers analysis of everyone backs up my theory even further. He has something to say about everyone, but is very dismissive of you and Nazarush.

I do not think the replacement action is so doubtful - as has been said, it might easily be an action done in fairness.

But as nmillar has just stated - he was very dismissive of both Titanium and Nazarush, while pointing towards me and nmillar (Perhaps we are beginning to come on to something here?), while dismissing most else as either incapable of being mafia (Such as dominic, which could easily be a trick), and the rest being townies for rather unwarranting reasons.

Such as his reasoning not to suspect Vitek - because he votes for nmillar and is very steadfast in his vote? That's more implying him to be mafia in my mind, as he's completely convinced nmillar must be lynched, but provides no convincing evidence.
GameRager also states GoJays to do the exact same thing as nmillar, but only suspects nmillar for it - and why? Because GoJays is more casual, or as you could rephrase - laid back. And then he goes on to claim that I must be mafia for seeming laid back... This does smell very fishy.

Clearly not a simple false positive tactic he could be orchestrating, even if he didn't get a mafia title. Although I would laugh my pants off if we went for the "first lynch the drunk, then the new guy" plan.

And I do like jokes... Unvote nmillar, vote GameRager

I agree with most of what you've said, except the bit I've quoted. Vitek believes I am a mafia member, so is continually voting for me, which is fair enough - he has stuck to his beliefs throughout and I'm therefore pretty sure he's not mafia. He mentioned something earlier about going to the forest, which suggestes he's a wood cutter / forest ranger - sounds plausible to me.

I suppose that is a fairly good explanation, but still such vehemence in voting is not really something that shines innocence in my eyes, so I will still watch him.

As per Titanium mentioning the scenario "First the drunk, then the new guy" is actually a very entertaining thought. Though we must keep in mind that FoolalooF's posts still count toward GameRager, even though it is not the same person who uttered them, for they still have the same roles.

Looking at FoolalooF - he has been inactive, silent and not made any suspecions at all - in fact his last post declared he would look into who he should suspect. He hinted at owning a store, and giving this as his reason to vote for a nolynch, which does not seem that profitable to me - simply put, one dead townie is better for business than two, sure, but 5 dead townies over 5 days is not better for business than 3 dead mafia members in 3 days. I could all so easily have been a plot to seem neutral and inactive to throw us off guard with the number of mafia. There have been the issue with the number of mafia members, And while this occured during the Robbeasy scandal, it was Tyler, another deceased townie who threw the hammer. I'm thinking that this could have been planned, that FoolalooF was meant to decide just before Robbeasy's end that he would vote for Robbeasy, but after the discussion on the number of mafia, they may have changed the plan to avoid seeming obvious and to hide the number of members.

Probably just a paranoid conspiracy theory, but either way, there it is. And adding GameRager's post on top of that... It does appear like the "First the drunk, then the new guy" might be the correct way to go.

Oh I don't want to lynch anyone that doesn't deserve it, so I did weigh my choices as carefully I could given how much I could glean from the past few pages of replies from each of the players. I still think Damnation is very suspicious for being so laid back while at the same time changing his vote from nMillar to undecided in such a short period. This stinks to me, and nMillar's constant posts seem twitchy and unhinged to me as well.....as if he is trying his best to hide something while falling apart inside all the while. .

Also, while nMillar IS more vocal of the two, that doesn't mean he is necessarily in charge of the mafia lurking in our town & it could easily be a distraction tactic from the true mastermind. I'd rather cut off the head of the snake to begin with than the tail anyways, so I will keep my vote for Damnation for the time being, unless evidence or replies from the various players change my mind in a major way one way or the other.

I have alot of time on my hands. That, and I actually want to win! :)

I feel I should clear this up.

Modkilling a player is always a last resort. When a player goes AWOL it is always preferable to have them replaced, if a replacement can be found.
Also, as a mod, I would never purposely let the relative power of the different factions influence any decision I make.
As such, I would not read anything into my decision to replace FoolalooF.

TL;DR:
Don't game the mod.

It's doubtful you can be convinced otherwise, GameRager, for your suspecion is quite misplaced and seems somewhat unfounded. Basing it solely on the fact that I changed my vote quickly is rather weak, as anyone can change their minds in any given time interval. If you must adhere to such theories, then everyone who has changed a vote, no matter the time interval, is as likely of being suspect because time is hardly a reliable factor - seeing as how, as I stated, anyone is capable of changing their mind at any given time. Furthermore, you have not addressed why GoJays is so innocent because of being laid back, while I apparently is guilty because of the very same thing.

That said, I must say there is some appreciation to be had towards your last reply, thinking me capable of running a group of organized criminals and not have them wish me dead by voting me out, that's not quite a quality I thought I had.

GoJays, I meant, is more laid back in how he researches the other players and lays it out for all to see. nMiller seemed to be doing the same thing, yet in a more frantic manner suggesting him as being mafia.

You though, are not laid back in general like GoJays is or seems to be, but rather MORE laid back than nMillar yet also as or more suspicious than him BECAUSE you are acting more laid back than him.......and your vote for nMillar then quick unvote in such a casual(laid back) manner screams to me that you are mafia, and nMillar is the patsy/fall guy of the group if one is ever needed, meant to detract attention from you and other other mafia members.

Looks like someone is frantically mis-spelling names now! :P

I'm not entirely sure what you mean by frantic though; all my posts have been my interpretation of the evidence laid before us all. Sure, I've changed my opinion of who I find suspicious a few times, but that's bound to happen as new evidence presents itself.

Screw that. If I was in the mafia, I'd be the Don.