Huzzey5: This was a tough one, but the winner is most definitely Arcanum, I just really like the concept / how it looks, Silver was in second, haha. There is a problem though. Robette said Arcanum first, yes, but part of the contest was to also convince me, something makr3la did much more of. If I could get you both prizes I would, but sorry makr3la is the winner!
I must also say though special mention to Azrael360 and Pseudonarne for suggesting that I get a 10$ game just for me and not give them a gift, for that they can have something special too, Robette as well. :) I'll PM everyone who won, but thanks to all who participated, especially Dirtyharry and Antimateria, that was fun!
Thanks Huzzey5. It was fun. In the meantime I dropped in on the ninja thread and actually scored a very nice prize thanks to Ian - Grotesque Tactics 1 and also 2! This means i get to venture forth and save lots of half-naked virgins! Yay!! :D