Well, what do you know? These are dynamically developing times. So a few more points before I'll really shut up (also to give the others an opportunity to chime in):

1) So we learned Ghost was a lyncher. The obvious question to ask is who was the lynchee? Now I did throw my answer to this question out here quite casually before, but as I reread this day so far, I can see that Robb suggested Damnation (#437), which is downright absurd, if you remember the whole Damnation lynch Robb himself is so keen to keep reminding us of; for explanation why is it so absurd, see Jess (2011:440). Orry, on the other hand, suggested Robb (#438), which is perhaps even more ridiculous, if you remember the whole Ghost lynch. Really, I should think Ghost's target was terribly obvious, and I'm finding it quite difficult to find these two glaring mistakes anything else but deliberate misdirections.

2) This is specifically for Robb, re: post 443
Again, for someone so adamant to draw D1 into this, it is very odd how you flat out ignore what happened that day. Town can't lie about their role? So what was it Damnation did, exactly?
In a way, it does, but then again, if you picked 7 people completely at random from the starting 12, it would still be quite likely there is at least one mafia among them. That doesn't really prove anything at all. And why do you ignore the entirety of D2, the meatiest part of the game, and keep coming back to something that was essentially a random lynch turned wrong?
By the by, this is something I have wanted to bring up for ages, but always forgot; now that I have to deal with time differences a lot, I remembered: we shouldn't forget that a large part of the Damnation lynch happened really, really fast. For myself, I literally slept through the whole thing (the hammer vote was cast at about 3 AM central European time, if I remember correctly) -- which is why I'm not willing to put much stock in who was on that wagon and who wasn't. If I were awake at the time Damnation claimed, I'd be on it, too.

3) Re: Jess' #444 -- yes, one of the reasons I rolled out that "lynching Ghost confirms Robb" theory in the open was to throw a feeler out there and see how Robb was going to react. The swiftness of his face-heel really was beyond expectations.

4) Re: Jess' #453
I think it has already been said here: it just doesn't feel right, does it? By now, it's pretty clear this setup is fairly complex. Uses some of the less common power roles (like jailer), possibly in unusual variations (like ability cop). And a mason/lyncher paired with a vanilla mason feels very out of place here. A mason/lynchee would indeed go well with it, but that is obviously not the case. I'd take a mason/tracker, for example, or a mason/vig, but vanilla mason seems far too... vanilla for this game. Not to mention "Jack White", which really feels like a lazy fakeclaim.

5) I still don't quite get where did that theory there's a third party around here come from. I went through the list of third party roles and while Damnation pulled off some pretty textbook Jester play, he was not a jester. A survivor I can imagine being here, yes. But other than that? Not really. And at this, LYLO-nearing stage, a good survivor is basically pro-town, anyway, and by its nature, it isn't really a role that would require changing the number of mafia from the standard 25%.

We are in a delicate situation. But I can honestly say that so far in this game, I haven't had a scum read as strong as I do on Robb right now. But I fully admit I need to broaden my perspective a bit now. If someone feels there's a good case to be made against anyone, go ahead, please. We need all the good cases we can open now.

Hi, I am still alive.
I moved on Saturday and have no internet connection yet. Right now I am posting from library but I have not enough time today to really contribute anything. I thought I'll have connection by Wednesday but the stupid ISP is taking its time. I'll try to post something more tomorrow but I can't promise anything.

I can't see that the two of you have posted within the last 72 hours. You have 48 hours to respond to this prod - by 23:00 UTC 23.04.

@Typhoon:
This is your third prod in this game. I would appreciate it if I wouldn't have to prod you again.

Just waiting for some solid proof.

I hope you're really, really patient then.

There never ever is solid proof - you have to look at all that has gone before and take a chance. Believe the attack on me - or believe otherwise. You have the most powerful role at the moment - use it wisely....

Well currently if ghost was right than you are town hmm, i will wait a bit

Yeah, sorry, I've had a crapload of stuff to deal with...

Meantimes, the game!

I think that Orryyrro is the scummiest person still clocking in today. His claim doesn't really fit, with no other inanimate objects having been named, and I think that that is a good enough reason for a lynch.

I know that earlier I said that I liked how it stood out, but that only pertained to when we only knew two other names. Unless anyone else would like to hint (not outright claim) that they too are but an object, I think that it's time to sweep the *Orry conspiracy* out of the door once and for all.

Vote Orryyrro

I suppose we can do that, I will vote againist him but If hes not mafia your screwed.

Oh, dear. Until now, I didn't quite realise it's only four to lynch. Don't do anything rash, Roosh!

Orry, you're at L-2 now. Considering your claim, there probably isn't much you can do to avert suspicion now, I suppose. Could we get a list of your reads, perhaps? I have noticed you seem reluctant to take a side in the whole Robb business. What do you think of that?

I don't think Robb being mafia is the most likely thing, I still think Typhoon is far more scummy than him. I'd advise against lynching me or anyone until we're sure since if there are 3 mafia that would mean we lose. However, as it stands it only requires one town vote to lynch (assuming 3 mafia), if Robb and/or Typhoon aren't mafia then I'm as good as dead. Seeing how I didn't have 3 people jump on my wagon and kill me either Robbeasy and/or Typhoon are mafia, there are only 2 mafia in this game or both.

Can anyone please post a list of current alive players
and what the role claimed or not.

Oh, very well then. I propose we start doing things the organised way. A mass claim. Full, if possible. Followed by a thorough cross checking of roles and night actions. I suggest doing it using the popcorn method, starting with current suspect number one, Orry. Those who have claimed before could repeat their claim, so we will get everything in one neat package.

Those in favour, say aye. Four ayes means we do this, and if someone doesn't comply, they get lynched.

I say aye (1).

Aye(2)

Aye (3)