roninnogitsune: I would be behind Nintendo's Good enough technology philosophy if they force these gimicks that just detract from the game than adding it.
Luisfius: Thing is, if those "gimmicks" detracted, then Sony and Microsoft would not have had to react with PSMove OR the Kinect. Alternative control schemes aren ot necessarily bad or inferior.
The Wii had the best third person shooter control scheme outside of point and click. It was not widely used, but damn if I wouldn't rather play RE4Wii than, well, whatever flagship TPS the PS3 or the 360 got. Gears of War and all.
It is only when it is BADLY implemented that it detracts from the experience, but there is nothing inherently wrong with the wiimote, and since the new WiiU screenpad has all the functionality of a regular dualshock/xbox pad plus the screen, that won't detract either.
Edit: Same with 3ds and DS, where did the two screen/stereoscopic 3d gimmick detract from the game?
The xbox CAN do games with alternate control, the WII HAS to. BIG difference.