Vitek: 2. He is mafia. This clears nmillar in my eyes (GameRagers voted for him). In case he gets lynched, unless it is some devious plot I don't understand, Titanium, Nazarush and eyeball226 are honest folks as well. This leaves Dominic998, Damnation and GoJays225 and two of them being mafia. And I stop suspecting Damantion long time ago. This means in case GameRager is mafia then Dominic998 and GoJays225 are mafia too. And this I don't belive.
Though it's true they are some of the least vocal players (until GameRager came). If they are mafia it paid off for them a lot so far. We were eager to lynch anyone who spoke his mind too much and they could only sit and watch.
Hmmm... now that I wrote it, it doesn't seem so unlikely. They were even the first three to vote the pointless nolynch on the first day.
First of all, well done for presenting the most reasoned argument to date.
I've highlighted your second option because I've checked the voting history and see that FoolalooF / GameRager, GoJays2025 and Dominic998 have never voted for each other. The last two are yet to cast their votes for today's lynch, so if you are correct they would have been waiting for another vote for either myself (before you retracted your vote) or Titanium.
This does cast a shadow of doubt over my earlier theory (i.e. Titanium, Nazarush, eyeball226) and I may have to reconsider my vote ...