But that's the problem, I forget who said it earlier (and am too lazy to go back through all the posts) but we don't have much more information now than we did on the previous day. Most of the suspicsions derive from the way in which someone's posting, more often than not an incorrect assumption. Although, I guess one must start somewhere.... No vote from me yet, this could be difficult.

On a side note, GoJays, Vitek, and Tyler have all had very little to say so far. I would appreciate if they would add their thoughts to the discussion and point out anyone they find suspicious so far.

That's another interesting point - Vitek and GoJays have been the least active, but Robbeasy accuses myself and eyeball of being mafia for that very reason.

I believe Robbeasy, Vitek and GoJays2025 are the 3 mafia.

wait, how do you know there are three mafia? I dont remember the exact number ever being given.

In mafia games, it's generally 25% of the participants that are designated as mafia. There were 12 at the start of the game, so from that I am assuming 3 mafia.

EDIT: 25% was mentioned in the thread asking for people interested in playing.

Interesting. One can only speculate that there are three mafia members active, by the numbers, but you seem positive from the start that there are three. It could be only two, while four might be too much, IMO.

On a further note, if nmillar IS one of the mafia, it is unlikely that those three that he pointed out are also mafia, since he wouldn't rat out on some of his colleagues, depending on how many there really are. So by "sacrificing" nmillar, we can speculate about the structure of the mafia gang. Three people under the light, if we're wrong, and one mafia out, three clear, if we're right and lynch a mafia member.

Sorry man, but Vote nmillar.

I think I've just eliminated myself by editing a post anyway.

Sorry was somehow busy.

I think, if nmillar really was mafia, then some of the people named by him could very well be mafia too, because this would make them appear as falsely accused and innocent. Quite good cover up
But I am propably speculating too much. :-)
And yes, I know I am one of them and have just almost accused myself. :-)

I suspect Robbeasy and Damnation to be mafie. Both of them. They try just too much to appear as falsely accused and I feel their disccusion was arranged beforehand to confuse us. Also I feel exactly opposite as Robbeasy. As mafia I would try not to be quite, this is too suspicious and therefore dangerous without real benefits for mafia.

I am really not sure who to vote but to get this day moving I say vote Robbeasy

It should be OK. You made it at the same minute you wrote it. I think this rule is mostly to forbid editing older posts to hide some infos.

Identical to what I said earlier, so I'll second your vote for Robbeasy.

While I consider nmillar's confident assertion that there are 3 mafia suspicous, I still have to go with my initial suspicion.

vote Robbeasy

I got the impression there were 3 as well, it said ~25% in the sign up thread and 12 divides into quarters pretty easily. ;)

I'm not very good at reading people (suck at poker) but the argument against Robbeasy is relatively compelling. Still, I'll reserve my vote until the discussion has continued more.

Zchinque wrote in his first post in the other thread there is gonna be 25% of mafia. I see no problem here I counted with 3 mafias too.
See.

My apoloies to nmillar, Vitek and Eyeball are right that Zchinque's post make it seem pretty obvious that there are three.

Just confirming that nmillar is not modkilled for that post edit. I consider this game in many ways a test run, so I want it to go by with as little interference as possible.

That said:
Don't edit posts or double post!

(I really hope the forum update next year will bring along a complete new forum software)

Am I right in thinking that double posting would be allowed if it wasn't for the fact that the forum merges them with an edit?